5 rounds judged
The category leader against the cheaper newcomer. Which one finishes the book?
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
Storyworth
$59 – $199 per year
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins on price and on pace: one flat £44, about $56, against a ladder that starts at $59 and runs to $199, and no fixed weekly schedule to fall behind. Storyworth wins on maturity and on the physical product at its upper tiers, and if colour photographs throughout matter more to you than the price, buy Storyworth and do not think about it again..
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
Voice-first against self-paced. Which suits a parent who will not type?
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
Remento
Around $99 per year
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins on price and on the length of what gets written — spoken answers run short, and a book of them is thinner than a book of typed ones. Remento wins the round that matters most if your storyteller genuinely will not type, and it wins the keepsake round outright: hearing the voice is something we do not offer and cannot claim to match..
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
The cheapest membership against the only service with no recurring charge.
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins on entry price and on the guided-question structure, which produces a fuller book than an open two-year window tends to. Meminto wins the terms round outright — a one-time payment with nothing to cancel is the cleanest arrangement anybody in this category offers, and if that is your deciding factor, buy Meminto rather than us..
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
Answer the questions yourself, or pay a professional to do the whole thing?
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
StoryTerrace
Premium, quoted per project
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins for most families on cost and on voice — the words in the book are the storyteller’s own. StoryTerrace wins decisively on completion: the work is the writer’s rather than your mother’s, and a book that gets finished beats a cheaper one that does not.
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
Good printing with a billing reputation, against a flat-price newcomer.
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
Memowrite
Auto-renewing subscription
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins on price clarity — one flat £44 with a single figure at checkout. Memowrite wins on the finished object: reviewers consistently praise its printing and photo reproduction, and report books arriving around ten days after submission, which is fast.
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
Fifty guided questions, or an AI that asks its own follow-ups?
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
StoriedLife
Tiered subscription
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins on price, on predictability and on who is doing the asking — a fixed set of questions is something a family can look at in advance and add to. StoriedLife wins the round that matters for a reticent storyteller: adaptive follow-ups pull more out of someone who answers briefly, and no static prompt list matches that..
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
Two similar products at different prices. Where does the money actually go?
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
My Life in a Book
$79 base, extra copies $40
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins on entry price — about $56 against $79 — and on answering by voice as well as by typing. My Life in a Book wins clearly on extra copies at $40 each, which matters enormously if there are four siblings who all want one, and it has a longer clean record on billing than we can claim..
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
A flat membership against a one-time package with guided phone calls.
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
Memorygram
$124.99 one-time
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins on price by a wide margin — about $56 against $124.99 — and on being self-paced rather than scheduled. Memorygram wins on the two rounds where money buys something real: guided phone calls get answers out of people who will not write, and a one-time package has nothing to cancel..
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
One person’s life story, or a book several relatives write together?
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins where the point is one person’s own account in their own words, which is what most people buying a memoir gift actually want. Keepsake wins outright where the storyteller is unwilling, unwell or already gone, and the memories live across a family rather than in one head..
Read all 5 rounds5 rounds judged
Is a life-story service worth three times the price of a fill-in book?
LifePages
getlifepages.com
£44 (about $56)
Winner
A guided memory journal
Various publishers
Around $20
Our winner: LifePages. LifePages wins on what comes out the other end: a typed or spoken answer becomes a properly printed book with photographs, and the questions keep arriving rather than sitting on a shelf. The journal wins on price, on simplicity and on one thing no service can offer — their handwriting.
Read all 5 rounds